Which One Is It, Linda? Democracy, Theological Education, and Institutional Neutrality

Last month, Education Secretary Linda McMahon stood on a stage at Vanderbilt University and praised its chancellor for insisting that a university’s purpose is “not to settle debates, but to create a home where the hardest ideas can be examined freely and fearlessly.” On its own, that sentence captures what scholars of religion and theology do for a living. In our classrooms, students remember the lives lost during the HIV crisis, discuss the role of faith in how constituencies vote, trace who farms the food we eat, and debate what authoritative texts mean. These are hard conversations about who we are as humans and how we flourish together. They shape us as citizens and are inseparable from building a stronger, healthier democracy. Yet according to McMahon, in that very speech, they are the problem.

Her remarks are too rich to unpack, but we find some snippets worth quoting. The overarching narrative is that universities have become an ideological weapon of the left. “Many disciplines abandoned the pursuit of knowledge altogether,” McMahon said, “redirecting their work toward political and social agendas like ‘anti-racism’ that reduce scholarship to activism.” Her sole example of an “intellectually hollow” project was a religious studies dissertation on “queer and transgender Thai Buddhist artists.” The topic itself was the indictment. Throwing transgender identities and studies under the bus featured prominently in the 2024 election. So did attacks on anti-racism and Black Lives Matter. If this topic does not meet the requirements of open inquiry, McMahon did not explain why. Which is it, Linda? Is it open inquiry, or adherence to your specific ideological agenda? Apparently, queer theory and critical race theory do not address the “hardest ideas.”

We should be clear about what we are not arguing. Academics have standards, and they are important. A doctoral thesis might not be well-argued or adequately documented, and it is the responsibility of mentors and evaluators to point that out. But a standard used from a podium to judge a title is a test of content, which is to say, a political test, which is to say, in this case, an ideological test.

Vanderbilt has endorsed the idea that much of the crisis in education stems from a deviation from academic standards, and it defines those standards in terms of institutional neutrality. We must acknowledge that we do not know what this means, especially when the institution welcomes the most ideologically driven Secretary of Education to campus. McMahon addressed the Vanderbilt community in line with Chancellor Daniel Diermeier and the Board of Trust’s recent declarations, praising the University for reclaiming “truth, institutional neutrality, and open inquiry.” She did so in a speech that called the 2024 election “a turning point for America — and for higher education” and asked every institution to “put Americans, and American interests, first.” Chancellor Danny parrots this anti-free-speech agenda, in the name of freedom, when he says he is worried about “the replacement of scholarly rigor by activism.” Which one is it, Danny? How do you define activism? From this side, you are starting to look like an activist yourself.  

 It is one thing for a university to decline to issue statements. It is an entirely different decision to hand a former professional wrestling executive a platform to predetermine which topics of scholarship best serve the nation. McMahon’s weaponization of Jewish students, for instance, to justify a current genocide (funded by the US) is just beyond the pale. This is, rather incontrovertibly, not a practice of neutrality.

Not even the document most often cited for institutional neutrality, the University of Chicago’s 1967 Kalven Report, demands this. The report states that if society imperils the university’s mission and freedom of inquiry, the university has an obligation to defend itself. McMahon described an alternative arrangement. The pressure from the administration, she argued, “provides the air cover” for university officials to undertake reforms, and she reported their “quiet appreciation.” We notice a parallel contradiction: just as financial capitalism claims to oppose state regulation while lobbying for favorable policies, these arguments advocate institutional neutrality while bullying institutions into self-imposed compliance.

This is no coincidence. The speech asks universities to foster “a thriving marketplace of ideas” and speaks of the taxpayer’s “investment.” The values at work in our classrooms are not necessarily antithetical to political regimes, but they are definitely opposed to capitalist drives. Churches and universities are some of the very last places where we are having these conversations. No wonder that even in a capitalist democracy they are being squeezed out and asphyxiated.

This fall our alma mater, Vanderbilt Divinity School, was placed under receivership, with the University’s central administration overseeing its budget, operations, and staff for up to two years. The University says the decision followed an independent review, which it has not released, and is unconnected to the Declaration of First Principles its Board adopted in June. That Declaration lists “receivership and closure” among the remedies for units whose faculty “subordinate scholarly standards to a political and social agenda.” We do not know why the decision was made, but the connections are hard to miss. As the school’s faculty chair, Phillis Sheppard told the Nashville Banner: “If they’re not connected, they’re definitely on very close parallel trains.” A deputy provost, calling it a path to rejuvenation, acknowledged that “in the real world, receivership means bankruptcy.” The market, again, supplied the word.

We write as theological educators to other theological educators because what is being tested in Nashville is unlikely to stay there. Vanderbilt’s recent status as the Trump administration’s model university is disastrous not only because we do not share its principles, but also because it leaves educational institutions in a feeble position to strengthen democracy itself. Paulo Freire and, after him, bell hooks called education the practice of freedom, in which people learn to read their world critically and take part in changing it. Squeezing out theological institutions and the humanities more broadly undermines citizens’ ability to come together to reflect on precisely those values that attend to capitalism’s victims, place a magnifying glass on the nefarious consequences of our unreined “progress,” and dream of a world in which not every activity must turn a profit.

Such reflection is not a violation of academic rigor. It is among the reasons for it. McMahon’s vision, grounded in an appeal to “Western civilization,” is a dystopian, distorted, politically driven misrepresentation of what theological education should stand for. Most importantly, it cheapens some of the values of “Western civilization” itself. Linda, are we supposed to talk about “Western civilization” while papering over the myriads of struggles that have led us to enjoy a rather fragile democracy? A home for the hardest ideas can easily accommodate a seminar on the HIV crisis, a debate on faith and voting, an investigation into who farms our food, and a discussion of what authoritative texts mean.

If these ethical reasons were not enough, there is also a strategic one. Chancellor Deiermeier further states: “I think what you have right now is an administration that (…) believes that universities have lost their way, have drifted dramatically to the left, and they want to use every tool in their arsenal to fix that or to change that.” Which is it, Danny? Neutrality or fighting the leftist agenda? Ultimately, the problem with aligning University policies with such hyper-specific political commitments, partisan even in this case, is that, as we have recently experienced with the “bluenami,” the political winds may shift dramatically from one cycle to the next. Danny, let Linda do her own thing. When you tie your vision for the University's future to a concrete party ideology, you risk irrelevance and corruption. Vanderbilt–and any other educational institution in higher ed–should stick to its purpose of asking the truly hard questions. We will maintain this home, and Vanderbilt should return its Divinity School to the community that created it.

Next
Next

Learning to Love the Nation